About

I’m a retired U. S. Air Force officer currently working as a Human Resources Manager with a global company.  I developed an interest in the American Civil War while a college student.  Since then I’ve collected books, videos, CDs, and magazines about the Civil War.  I’ve participated in internet discussions, attended conferences, read the blogs of others, and discussed the war with historians.  I’ve learned quite a bit on this journey and have developed an appreciation for more than just the Civil War, but the entire history of the United States, because to really understand why the war came about you have to understand United States history from colonial times to the outbreak of the war, and to understand the war’s legacy you have to understand United States history from the end of the war to the present day.

All the opinions I publish in this blog are my opinions only and do not reflect the views of the United States Government or any other entity.

62 comments

  1. Mr. Mackey: Can you please refer me to a source on Prof. Gallagher’s view re O.O. Howard at Chancellorsville? ‘twould be most helpful, this week, especially. … “Gary Gallagher’s assessment was that Howard had behaved very well during the fighting.” ,,, Clint Schemmer, cschemmer@gmail.com

    1. That came directly from Chuck Teague’s presentation. He didn’t give a source in it.

  2. Thank you, sir. I enjoy your posts.

    1. Thank you very much.

  3. Very interesting. How many Union ancestors do you have that fought in the War? Do you have any information on their service?

    1. I don’t have any Union ancestors who fought in the Civil War.

  4. Sorry, I guess I asked the wrong question.
    How many confederate ancestors do you have that fought in the war?

    1. No need to apologize. I also don’t have any confederate ancestors who fought in the Civil War.

  5. Hi Al, perhaps I made a mistake assuming you still are located in Virginia, but I was looking for you today, yesterday now, special Battle of Brandywine Station battlefield tour.

    1. Hi Mike. No, I’m not in Virginia anymore. Yesterday I was at Gettysburg for the first battlewalk of the year. Troy Harman did a walk on the 11th Corps on the First Day.

      1. It was a most excellent tour and they will do it again. Except for the ticks, highly recommended.

        1. This appears to be a banner year for ticks. Presented as a public service: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sYijKB9o7B0&feature=youtu.be

  6. Barb Branco · · Reply

    Dear sir, Thank you for your very informative paper concerning the “Burning of Columbia”. I am a very proud descendant of Capt. William H.H. Goodrell who was there at Columbia S.C. during this period of the Civil War. My great, great grandfather was credited with capturing the South Carolina flag off the capital building and replacing it with the US flag. There are so many conflicting reports of the tragedy that occurred because of the fires. I was very glad to read your account that reiterates what he had written in the 1870’s as he recalled the incident.

    1. You’re very welcome, Ms. Branco. Has his account been published?

  7. Barb Branco · · Reply

    Sir, While on the website “Chronicling America” and typing in “William H. Goodrell”, I was able to find a newspaper article from The Memphis Daily Appeal dated Sat. Sept.20, 1873 (Image 2). It was a letter written by William that was his recollection of the fires. There is also another letter written by Major Kennedy who was with him when they entered the city. Generals Sherman and Belknap had requested their stories. It seems these men were answering questions for years.

    1. Thanks. I found the letter and will read it right now. I see there is also a letter from Sherman and one from Belknap along with these.

  8. Mr. Mackey: I stumbled across your blog in the course of my research about by 3rd-great-grandfather who served in the 123rd Illinois, part of Wilder’s Lightning Brigade. Someday I would like to plan a visit to the various Civil War battlefields he fought on, especially Perryville and Chickamauga. My question for you is, are there expert tour guides available for hire at places such as these? I would really like to make the most of my visits at these places. You seem like the kind of person who might have some advice for me…Thanks.

    1. Hi. Perryville is a State Historical Park. I would recommend contacting the park manager. His email address is at this website:
      http://www.parks.ky.gov/parks/historicsites/perryville-battlefield/default.aspx
      You can also get more information about the park at that website, including maps. It talks about group tours of ten or more people, but the park manager may be able to put you in touch with someone who can guide a smaller group. I think you’ll also find this website useful in learning about what happened: http://www.civilwar.org/battlefields/perryville.html
      A good book to get is Ken Noe’s Perryville: This Grand Havoc of Battle.

      The website for the Chickamauga and Chattanooga National Military Park is here: http://www.nps.gov/chch/index.htm
      Since it’s part of the National Park Service, there are a number of free ranger-led tours available. The website should have the schedule. Some battlefields, such as Gettysburg and Antietam, have licensed battlefield guides associated with them. These are independent contractors not affiliated with the National Park Service. They drive your car around the battlefield and give you a personalized tour for a fee. I haven’t heard of any LBGs at Chickamauga/Chattanooga, but that might be a question to ask the park. There are a number of books available on Chickamauga. There is a US Army War College Guide available in paperback, as well as Peter Cozzens’ book, This Terrible Sound, and a book of essays called The Chickamauga Campaign edited by historian Steven Woodworth. You can also download this National Park Service book: http://www.nps.gov/history/history/online_books/civil_war_series/10/
      You may also find this website helpful: http://www.civilwar.org/battlefields/chickamauga.html

      I hope that helps.

      1. Thank you so much!

        1. You’re very welcome. Best of luck enjoying retracing your relative’s route.

  9. Rosemary Kubera · · Reply

    Honorary Doctorate…. seems appropriate….who could disagree?
    ……My Dad was Army Air Corps man……
    Looking forward to reading your blog… happy to find good Cvl War site.

    1. Thank you for the kind words. I think I would have to disagree on the honorary doctorate at this time, though. There is still much to learn.

  10. marc panero · · Reply

    I recently discovered your blog (it is so much more than that). I wish to thank you for the time and trouble you take which keeps us informed of all aspects of the civil war. I, somewhat like you. am a student of the war, but I live on the west coast, and am not able to visit civil war battle fields as much as I would like. Your insights and postings of video links are a joy. I visit your site daily. Thank you, thank you, thank you.

    1. Thank you for the kind words. Keep up the study.

  11. Doug Murray · · Reply

    [Not published by request of the commenter]

    1. Thank you for your comments, Doug.

  12. Mr. Mackey,

    I just wanted to let you know that I’ve really enjoyed your blog so far. I discovered it when looking up the ownership of Fort Sumter and your links helped me a great deal. I’ve since been reading several other posts and found them informative as well as well written. I’m still rather new to this field, having only really started reading up on it in the last six months (I majored in classical history and Greek litterature) so I’m always on the prowl for more sources and good writers. This fits both of those.

    I like the atmosphere you try to maintain and very much appreciate the civil tone you strive for.

    You’ve certainly acquired a new reader today.

    1. Thank you very much for your kind words, Mr. Paulsen. I’m gratified to know that I could be of assistance in some small way.

  13. Rosemary · · Reply

    Hi, Mr. M.
    Have you seen video of Bruce Levine, interview by Mass. Law School dean on Levine book “Fall of House of Dixie” – two parts on youtube. Really interesting, I didn’t see it posted here tho maybe I missed it… anyway, you’d like it. Best wishes, R

    1. I haven’t seen this yet. Thanks.

  14. Rosemary · · Reply

    Not been to Gettysburg since my “Civil War awakening” (slept through the trip back in high school)… I’ve been listening to Carol Reardon talks and realize your blog photo has you with pup Sandy at one of the PA monuments. Pretty sweet,.

    1. Sallie. 🙂 She was the mascot of the 11th Pennsylvania Infantry. Sallie is a great example of why you have to get out of your car on the battlefield. If you stay in your car you’ll never see her, because she’s on the side opposite the road.

  15. Of interest though completely different: part of our culture commerated Gettysburg last November…. or….. Yankees did Gettysburg on a football Saturday (Dixie not an isssue 🙂 )
    PS I’m not an alum…. really,

  16. PS: yes, the Hokies beat them this year… eh…. One day the Golden Flashes WILL RISE
    Also: video ends at 10 minutes in..

  17. Oh, pleeze… she gives me Ohio State, I mean OHIO STATE! and its Marching Band for cripes sake… ugh… a guy runs a blog and gets all kinds of ….
    🙂
    I would not offer a regular marching band thing, good sir. These guys rarely stay still.. they make stick figures of soldiers march across the field to Battle Cry of Freedom…. they make a horse rear up.. and shoot a cannon at the opponent’s goal post (hey – maybe it was Virginia Tech?)
    I respect going with no comment… I mean …10 minutes of one’s life for Ohio State is a lot to ask unless a paycheck is involved.
    Yet self-proclaimed students of the Civil War, imo, ought not confine themselves to dead guys, crazy guys, and the boys from ivory towers.
    Schmaltz is part of it. In 2066 someone is going to present a paper on this kind of stuff.
    Just sayin’ …..

    1. Please don’t think I don’t appreciate the contribution. Brooks and Kevin both highlighted it last year, so I didn’t think much more needed to be said about it.

  18. ah….. makes sense….

  19. Hi. I have been enjoying your recommended links very much. Thanks for posting! I think I found something you might like. “Great Battles of the Civil War” presented by Allan W. Howey … it is part of 2013 series presented by Dayton, Oh area university and public library re Lincoln… Speaker is very good. You probaby have heard him … but I’ve mined your video archive and didn’t see this talk included…
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l3Tl2LX6_JE

    1. Thanks for the video. He should probably update his lecture, though. 🙂

  20. Me, again.
    You are the only person in the world who I can share my videos with… My circle just isn’t into the Civil War.. no matter how many great stories I can tell…. anyway,,,, Here is a Tim Smith vid that might be new to you. It was a Smith talk that got me into the CW in the first place. …. The intro for this vid is kinda drippy.. but once Tim comes on, it is great. This is about Gttysburg civilians.

    1. Thanks again. My cat listened for awhile but then he decided he wasn’t interested in Gettysburg civilians. I, however, watched the whole video. Thanks for contributing.

  21. ‘Fraidy cat no doubt couldn’t stand upcoming part where Tim tells of enterprising civilians who, confronted with thousands of starving soldiers, invented Feline Stew.
    He’ll like this one …. if he’s not German:

    1. Thanks, Rosemary. I’ve adjusted the link to the beginning of the playlist so that someone clicking on it will start at the first lecture.

      I did a small Gettysburg Battlefield tour with Christian in 2013. I think what I’ll do is separate the Civil War talks that I haven’t featured yet and make posts of them. The Perspectives in Military History series is terrific. I’ve attended several of them.

  22. Mark Welsh · · Reply

    I’m searching on info in my family tree and came across a Steven Blevins of Ashe, North Carolina that was killed 1 July 1863 at Gettysburg. He was born in 1832. Wondering if we’re kin or you have more info? He was married to Jane Mink born in 1836 also from Ashe. By the way, I’m an Air Force veteran also. 🙂

    Mark Welsh
    Shelbyville, Tennessee

    1. Sorry, I don’t have any more information on him.

  23. Marc Panero · · Reply

    I really enjoy your website. I have posted here before. But I feel I am becoming a student of the “Student of the American Civil War”. You do not know how much I enjoy your postings, and how many hours I spend watching and reading them. Thank you so much for the time and care you spend to keep up the site.

    1. Thank you for your kind words. I’m very happy to hear you find the posts enjoyable.

  24. Willie McBain · · Reply

    I guess I feel dumb after reading your well-constructed post of the question on the following question. At lunch last week I gravely pronounced that if Abe Lincoln had merely been a better lawyer — better able to bring two opposing sides together — we might have avoided the Civil War long enough for mechanization to make slavery obsolete.

    The topic was the battle flag business and the general reluctance of some to forget the war. I have no dog in the hunt except it seems a little stupid from both sides. Do you have an opinion about how long slavery might have survived as an institution if there had not been secession and war? Okay, slavery was booming at the time. At some point surely it would have failed. Or would it have?

    1. Thanks for the comment and question. The idea that slavery was on the way out and would be obsolete is a very popular notion. I’ve found that popular notions need to be questioned, because many times they aren’t right. This is one of those times. The historical record is clear on a number of facts. First, slavery was incredibly profitable wherever it was tried. Second, the institution of slavery was remarkably resilient. Third, it survives in some forms to the present. Fourth, people were willing to sacrifice everything to preserve it. Regarding mechanization, we need to remember that mechanization makes labor more efficient, not unnecessary. Mechanization of agriculture hasn’t eliminated the need for agricultural labor. That’s why we still have armies of migrant workers. Additionally, an enslaved person can perform any type of labor.

      I don’t think it’s impossible that legal slavery could have survived through the 20th Century, even to the present. Imagine a society where the free are a leisure class, with that leisure being built on the backs of enslaved people. Does it remind you of an episode of Star Trek? It should. Sci Fi explores possible outcomes.

  25. Mike Rogers · · Reply

    Al – I found the Jefferson reference I mentioned when we were talking the United States “are” or “is”. It’s in Bernard DeVoto’s Course of Empire on page 403. “Or more simply, this: after 1803 the phrase “the United States” in Jefferson’s writing, usually plural up to now, begins increasingly to take a singular verb.”

    This is at the end of a section in the book about the Louisiana Purchase and he ties the notion of a continental nation to Lincoln’s 1862 message to Congress.

    1. Thanks for checking on it, Mike.

  26. John Heagney · · Reply

    Just discovered your blog while researching reasons for secession. In St. Louis Mo. (my home town) a flurry of letters to the editor regarding the fate of an early 20th century Confederate monument included 3 or 4 spouting the neo-Confederate view that the war was about a lot more than slavery, tariffs were the primary cause etc. Thank you for your work in gathering together the messages of the various southern secession conventions outlining the reasons for their actions.

    Regarding your ground rules governing “Comments” I try to refrain from moving the furniture in a house I do not own. Allow me to especially endorse rule 9.

    May Sallie live forever and keep up the good work

    1. Thanks very much for taking the time to comment.

  27. I’ve recently discovered your work, as well. And I can’t thank you enough for all of the work you’ve put into this. Especially, your cite work.

    I’ve been lurking for about a month, but I have to break my silence. I’ve found references to the 1860 census showing around 30% of slave state families owned slaves. But, for the life of me, I can’t find it in the source. Do you have a direction you could point me in?

    1. Thanks for your kind words and for taking the time to comment. You can estimate the percentage of slave-owning families in each state for any year, but some years the estimate is less reliable than others. If you look at the results of the census in some years you’ll see number of slave owners in a state as well as the number of households [households = families] in the state. We know that only one person in a household could be the slave owner, it’s a simple matter of dividing slave owners by households and multiplying the quotient by 100% to get the percentage of slave-owning households. In other years the number of households isn’t available. Then we have to make an assumption to come up with an estimate. We can assume a household consists of an average of 4-5 people, so we divide number of free people by either 4 or 5, whichever we want to choose for the estimate, and that gives us an estimate of number of families, then proceed as above, realizing it’s an estimate based on an assumption regarding the average number of people in a family. We should always qualify our statements based on that estimate with that assumption. This source says they’ve computed the percentages based on the 1860 Census, though I haven’t verified their numbers at this point.

      1. Thank you for the quick reply.

        I’ve found that site, too. I also found this from the Library of Virginia: http://mapserver.lib.virginia.edu/php/state.php

        Lots of sortability!

        Again, thank you so much for all the work you’ve done.

  28. As a serious amateur scholar of American history, and Civil War history in particular, (as well as an USAF veteran myself), I’m so pleased to have discovered your blog site. Excellent! I bookmarked it for frequent future visits.
    In a time where many wonder where are the vaunted heights to which the internet was predicted to rise, your site is a terrific example. Thanks again.

    1. Thank you for your very kind words.

  29. You have a great site here, and I enjoy your perspectives. I am the descendant of UNION veterans of the War of the Rebellion, and I was born in …… Gettysburg. Love your work.

    (I don’t know if you’re a wrestling fan as well as a football fan, but it was nice to watch my Nittany Lions wrestle your Hokies. I believe there is also a home-and-home football series between the two schools in the next decade. Should be fun.)

    1. Thank you very much for the comments. Yes, if I recall correctly the series is somewhere around 2021 or 2022.

  30. bob carey · · Reply

    Al,
    I don’t know where else to place this on your blog but Happy Veterans Day and thank you for your service.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: