Field of Lost Shoes: Lost Cause Claptrap Movie

Here’s a link to view the movie, if you can stand it:

Now, I’m on record as stating that you can’t expect accuracy from Hollywood.  Hollywood is about entertainment, not history.  I’m not retreating one iota from that stand; however, for a historical movie to work there has to be enough accuracy to create verisimilitude.  That’s a word I learned in high school.  It refers to enough accuracy to make the plot believable.  It has to seem real enough to us that we suspend our disbelief and involve ourselves emotionally in the film.  There is just so much wrong with this movie that I found that to be impossible.

The movie starts with historical nonsense.  The voiceover narration claims former Virginia Governor Henry Wise had changed his mind about slavery, which is simply something the writers made up out of thin air.  It proceeds from there to even more nonsense:  the claim that Wise took his son to a slave auction in order to show him how evil slavery was.  This is where the filmmaker makes the statement that he’s not trying to defend slavery, that he agrees slavery was a wrong.  We’ve seen this from lost causers quite a bit.  “Oh, I agree slavery was horrible and I’m not defending it, but …” and then they go on to defend slavery.  The movie also makes the ridiculous claim that Henry Wise opposed secession.  This was the same Henry Wise who sent troops to Harpers Ferry and the Gosport Navy Yard before Virginia seceded because he was concerned they wouldn’t secede and he wanted to push them along.

The movie purports to tell the story of the VMI cadets who participated in the 1864 Battle of New Market in the Shenandoah Valley.  We follow John Sergeant Wise, son of the former governor, through the fabricated lesson of the evils of slavery from his father into VMI, where he and his classmates are paragons of antislavery, even going so far as to volunteer to be hanged in place of a slave in order for him to be released.  Quite obviously, slavery had to have nothing to do with the war since the confederates loved black folks and did all they could to help them.  Riiiiiiight.

Of course United States soldiers are depicted as savage, bloodthirsty, and ready to destroy everything they could get their hands on, whereas the virtuous confederates stop to help all the black folks in trouble who were fleeing the marauding Yankees.  The scenes in the White House are just silly, and Grant is shown vowing to “burn that valley to cinders” just out of pure spite.

When we get to the battle we see the VMI cadets impulsively charging a Union battery to capture the guns.  In the movie, the battle is conducted in sunshine and blue skies, but as they cross a muddy field they lose their shoes.  In reality, the battle was fought in a thunderstorm, which caused the muddy field, which cause them to lose their shoes.  At the end we see the slave from VMI who is suddenly at New Market, crying over the bodies of the people who fought to keep him enslaved.

Neoconfederates will love this movie, no doubt.  Anyone who has the first idea of what actually happened in the Civil War will want to have that hour-and-a-half of their life back.  You’ve been warned, so don’t blame me if you choose to watch it.



  1. As I pointed out in my dissertation/first book, Wise worked very hard and openly in the1850s to help spread slavery into the Virginia mountains so that the commonwealth would be united on a pro-slavery basis before any civil war. Later, had the Virginia convention not voted to secede after Sumter, Wise was ready to overthrow it with force and essentially lead an armed coup. The New Market story is dramatic enough without resulting to fantasy.

    1. Thanks, Ken. You’re absolutely right that they could have had a good, dramatic story had they simply stuck to the facts. Unfortunately, the filmmakers chose to delve deeply into fantasy.

  2. Pat Young · · Reply

    Too bad. I am always hoping for a good youth oriented film to draw in young people.

  3. Prof. Noe, could you give us the title of that book? I might want to check it out.

      1. Yep, thanks Al.

  4. Thank you for debunking the myth that the only reason Virginia seceded was because they opposed Lincoln’s use of force against South Carolina.

    I just started working on a play. I want to tell the story of Robert J Breckinridge from 1849, when his nephew was elected to Congress, to the time that same nephew returned home. I’m having trouble finding reliable information on line so I will appreciate any suggestions concerning the story of the Breckinridge family. Thank you.

  5. Todd Owens · · Reply

    i fell asleep half way through the movie !!!

  6. Are any of you familiar with the play “Dont Cry For Me Margaret Mitchell” ?
    It’s the story of how the movie “Gone With The Wind” was made.

  7. Would you consider “Gone With the Wind” to be a lost cause claptrap movie?

    1. Yep. It gives a “slavery wasn’t so bad” “moonlight and magnolias” view of the Old South.

  8. I just tried to watch this movie on Netflix, as it’s being promoted on there. I knew by the slave auction scene I was in for a real winner. By the time the boys broke ranks and rushed over to help the slave woman trapped under the wagon I was already re-naming it ‘Field of Lost Cause Dreams’. I didn’t make it to the battle, as I began my online search for others’ opinions about the movie which led me here.

    It’s really too bad that as we roll up on the 150th anniversary of the end of the Civil War we as a nation have still not succeeded in coming to grips with either its causes or its continuing impact.

  9. Good take all around. I like your stuff very much.

    1. Thank you for visiting and commenting.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: